I bait my squirrel traps with Peanut butter on a cracker. I use 2 door live trap, place the bait at one end and only set one door. That way the critter has to cross the trap pan twice to get to the bait and out.
My best catch was 2 at once in a live (Hav-A-heart) trap.
My best catch was 2 at once in a live (Hav-A-heart) trap.