Prepared Society Forum banner

Home Heating Choices

16604 Views 52 Replies 37 Participants Last post by  LincTex
So, last night made me think.

It was very cold outside.

Our propane service said they would be coming to fill our tanks this week - and it looks like they did NOT because we ran out of propane on the coldest night of the winter.

We are in North Carolina - so it does not normally get this cold, but I am guessing it was around 11 degrees.

I pulled out two space heaters, that I thought would do the trick - until THE POWER WENT OUT.

We were stuck using the fireplace, which everyone knows is not energy efficient. Most of the heat went up the chimney... it did help a little... but not much.

I was told, that our chimney pipe cannot handle a wood burning stove... when it was put in, it was hooked up to propane... I had it switched over so we could burn wood.

I am tired of dealing with the propane company. What are your experiences with home heating, and what do you suggest?
21 - 40 of 53 Posts
maybe a lil off topic but, I've always been a firm believer in wood stoves, my grandmother had one of the most efficient stoves I've ever experienced until the insurance adjuster visited her home recently, turns out her insurance company threatened to drop her unless she changed her stove. the adjuster just so happened to have the number of a company that can help her out with a more 'efficient and safer' model. 3500 bucks later she now has a piece of crap thin gauge steel/glass stove that puts out only a fraction of her all old 'iron pig'. this doesn't sound safer either, tempered glass on not.

do I smell scam here?
I am smelling a scam here too ... time to contact a lawyer!
ever thought of solar radiant floor heating?
basically, its piping or hoses that coil through your flooring.
the pipes connect to a solar collector on your roof. a 12 volt pump slowly circulates antifreeze/water through the system giving you heat.

i am currently in the planning stage for building. this method seems most attractive to me. then have a wood stove for backup.
ever thought of solar radiant floor heating?
basically, its piping or hoses that coil through your flooring.
the pipes connect to a solar collector on your roof. a 12 volt pump slowly circulates antifreeze/water through the system giving you heat.

i am currently in the planning stage for building. this method seems most attractive to me. then have a wood stove for backup.
You probably could pipe some of the water through a double-wall of the wood-stove to boost your warming capability where the inner-wall is nearest the fire and the outter-wall would have pipe just close enough to collect the warmth without getting so hot that the floor would end up way too hot to walk on.
Most importantly would be the insulation in your home. I redid my floors last summer with some new thicker insulation and now my bedroom stays comfortably warm without any heat on while it is around 40 degrees outside.
So, last night made me think.

It was very cold outside.

Our propane service said they would be coming to fill our tanks this week - and it looks like they did NOT because we ran out of propane on the coldest night of the winter.

We are in North Carolina - so it does not normally get this cold, but I am guessing it was around 11 degrees.

I pulled out two space heaters, that I thought would do the trick - until THE POWER WENT OUT.

We were stuck using the fireplace, which everyone knows is not energy efficient. Most of the heat went up the chimney... it did help a little... but not much.

I was told, that our chimney pipe cannot handle a wood burning stove... when it was put in, it was hooked up to propane... I had it switched over so we could burn wood.

I am tired of dealing with the propane company. What are your experiences with home heating, and what do you suggest?
Here are some of our back up heating options for NG, electric and propane.

We have 3 - vent free Glo-Warm Blue Flame Heaters back up NG heaters.

GloWarm blueflame heaters are vent free heaters

Made 2 manifolds with ball valves that can be added to my forced air gas supply and to the gas line of the water tank. These heaters require no electric. I used some these heaters last fall when a bird got into my forced air furnace and destroyed the turbo fan. Heater man could not get here for 3 days so they took the chill off the 30 degree weather.

Also have 3 - Mr. Heater Portable Buddy space heaters â€" Model# MH9B that run on propane.

They run for days on a 20 pound cylinder.

If I had to do it over I would buy 3 catalytic propane heaters.

Olympian Wave 8 Catalytic Safety Heater - $299.99

Much more expensive than blue flame or infrared propane heaters. But, they just sip the propane for much longer burn times. The issue with catalytic is they are delicate and you must cover the catalytic pad or it gets ruined easily if contaminated.

And have 4 Milk House electric heaters

Amazon.com: Aloha 1,500-Watt Fan-Forced Milkhouse Heater: Kitchen & Dining

Just wished I had some wood fired back up heat. Never gave wood heat a though until 2007 when I first learned about Peak Oil...then it was too late. Can't afford to move now, so making due with what I got.

The houses nowadays are not set up for peak fossil fuel issues and are pretty much run by NG in my local. Our houses designs could not be worse for trying to heat with wood.

As a last ditch effort, erect a small tent inside with weights instead of stakes to hold the ends down. Or buy a self erecting pop up tent. 2 or 3 of you get in the tent can keep you from freezing.

Get some cold weather down sleeping bags. And be prepared with the proper mountaineering gear to keep you warm...you wont freeze inside your house with this stuff!

OR Windblocker hat
Seirus Quick Draw hat / face
Down Vest
Down coat
Wicking long underwear
Sweats pants, crew top with hoodie over crew top.
Thermal ski pants
Wool socks
North Face Down Nuptse Bootie III
OR Alti mitts
Power stretch glove liners under the Alti mitts.
See less See more
We use wood heat. Allen-Idaho has a great point about insulation. In emergencies cut down to one room and heat it. Had this converstion with a friend this morning. In my childhood days at my grandparent's farm they heated the "main room" during the winter. Bedrooms were not heated but had piles of blankets available. It was the best sleep I ever got underneath the weight (and warmth) of five or six quilts breathing the cold air in the bedroom. Evenings were spent playing cards or games near the wood stove where the whole family was gathered. This was in Kansas and it does get cold in the winter there.
wood insert fireplace rule... you can run it without power and all the energy to run it is local
I would go wood heat all the way.With maybe a few propane room heaters as backup.But before you switch to any new heating option,seal up your house.Weatherstrip,add insulation,thermal curtians for the windows,etc.With wood heat(assuming you have a place to cut your own),you are your fuel company.Plus,cutting wood is alot better exersize then writing checks out to the fuel companys,right??
We have a wood stove that extends into the room from the fire place in our basement and we had couches that pulled into beds. Many times in the early 80s we had to sleep down there.The electric would go out. And cooking on the top of the wood burning stove was great!
We have a wood and coal burning furnace but never use it. We have a lot of coal stored too. It is hard to start it.
We are earth sheltered, so the lowest it will get in the back rooms is about 55 degrees.
We insulated the walls between earth sheltered part of the home and the atmosphere exposed part of the home.

We have TWO propane tanks, when ONE gets empty, we call for more.
That way we ALWAYS have one tank in reserve.
We live quite a way off the beaten track, so it often takes a week for them to get here, and that is *IF* the minimum wage guy driving the truck and find the place!

If not, we wait another week to get on the schedule, and hope this driver can find his way around his hat without getting lost...

----------------------------------------

There are some pretty efficient RADIANT propane heaters out there, and one hooked up to a PORTABLE RESERVE TANK, like a grill or fork truck tank will heat up quite an area.

You WILL have to ventilate, and if you don't already have a carbon monoxide detector with battery back up, and you have propane heat, there is something wrong with you! :confused:

I have a propane radiant that attaches right to the top of the tank and will heat any given room to a comfortable temp.
Great to have an extra tank and that heater in reserve!

Radiant heaters are MUCH LOWER EMISSIONS than something like an open flame grill, which WILL kill you in short order!

I sometimes use kerosene heaters in the shop.
Kerosene is MESSY to use, stinks, but gives pretty good heat.
MUST BE VENTILATED!
Kerosene makes a Lot of carbon monoxide, so ventilation and carbon monoxide detector is required.
I prefer propane, but Kerosene is my 'Back Up' and stores pretty well.

I know you can't do this as are retrofit, but radiant floor heat is a good thing.
Cost us about $350 for a wood/coal/corn fired boiler as a back up when we installed the radiant floor heat.
Takes about an hour to get the backup boiler fired up, making heat, and get the valves/pumps switched over (Solar/Batteries, we are never without electricity) for the boiler to start working if something happens with the propane/electric boiler...

Something to consider if you go 'Off Grid' or build from 'Scratch',
Nothing quite as flexible, or quite as comforting as radiant floor heat,
And it's SUPER efficient to boot!
---------------------------------------

To stop what happened to you from happening again,

INSULATE THE CRAP OUT OF THE OUTER WALLS AND THE CEILING/ROOF!
Keeping heat in, even foundation or basement heat will keep pipes from freezing, and keep more of your hard paid for heat generation from leaking out!
Remember, the heat as to go somewhere for cold to creep in!
So fill those cracks, and insulate!

Consider a 'Secondary' heat source,
Not to heat the home to a 'Comfortable' level, but make it 'Livable' with some blankets/sweaters.

Kerosene heaters are a pain, they stink, they are dangerous, but they WILL keep the pipes from freezing and your nose from forming 'Snotsicles' (snot Popsicle)!

Propane grill tanks and radiant heaters will do the same, but you don't get the same BTUs/Heating time from the storage space.
On the other hand, Propane is useful for a number of things, doesn't go bad in storage, and is SAFER to store than Kerosene.

I use it for the grill, for cutting gas in the shop, for 'Camp Lights' and 'Camp Heat', and I have a propane powered vehicle (also burns gasoline, dual fuel).
See less See more
Carbon-Neutral Alternative Fuel Of the Future!

Lots of great ideas and comments, I find there are so many choices for different heating sources! I prefer the Carbon-Neutral Alternative Fuel Of the Future!!! WOOD! I like the idea behind wood burners for many reasons, Some of which are:
1 .Clean heating source
2. Gives me a reason to go outside
3. Lets me play with an axe
4. I love fire!
5. Junk mail receptacle
6. Wood Ashes would be great for my Compost pile!
7. Cost

On Homesteadearth.com we have a table that shows annual cost, installation prices, efficiency and a few other things in a hand Cheat Chart!
The old wood burning cooktop stove is hard to beat. And you should maximize the whole system. Take a look at these options:
Durango Woodburning Stove with Blower - TR008
Get a stove that has a blower, and there are additions you can add, such as a stove pipe heater, which blows even more heat into the room. Then there are other additions that can be piped into the rooms, all off the one stove.
I hope some one can help me out. I live in a single wide with electric heat and no place to put a wood stove. Last year we lost power for 5 days. Any more info on back up heating?
an outside wood burner would be a soluition but would have to set up so the heat will still rise into the house without power to blow it. Or some kind of 12v backup that you can run off a vehicle or a small solar set up. I would be suprised if there isn't a exterior wood burner that is already set up to get heat in without electricity though. obviously it's gonna be alot less efficient without fan forced air to move that heat but it would get you through a short outtage without frozen water lines and frozen people. Kero sene or ventless propane is probably much more convienient though. I really like the buddy heaters and they have a good low oxygen cut off system and a very sensitive turn over shut off.
I like the idea of the outside wood furnace, yes they use a lot of wood and they smoke a lot, but, if you have forced hot air heat now, you run your hot water line to a heat exchanger that goes in your existing plenum, if you have radiators or radiant floor heating it goes to that supply line. You can even heat a hot water heater with it for domestic use. A small solar panel and one battery will run your pump and blower. No worries of running out of propane or oil or the electric going out. Just gotta cut wood. Oh they have a blower inside that fires up when more heat is called for in the home.
The cheapest brand new one I saw browsing online was around 5k.
I hope some one can help me out. I live in a single wide with electric heat and no place to put a wood stove. Last year we lost power for 5 days. Any more info on back up heating?
You're screwed.

I would consider a backup generator that has enough uumph to run some lights and your electric heaters. Invest in a transfer switch and have an electrician wire it into your panel. Are you renting or is the unit yours?
The wood stove I have has a 4"x6" door and sits in a 1960's
metal kitchen cabinet that is 24"x24"x36".
My chimney is 3" auto exhaust.
You would not believe the heat I get from this tiny thing.
The auto exhaust pipe can be shaped to go out a window
or ceiling by any muffler shop.
My horse drawn home is only 6x16 but I have a curtain for
a door and cracks between the floorboards so dust and hay
sift out.
It is 28 outside and 67 inside.
Boats used to use tiny wood stoves.
And they still make beautiful little cast iron jobs at REAL $$$
My stove was made for a tent or ice fishing hut and cost
$200 new and worth every penny.
The pipe cost $40.
The roof cap was $7.00
See less See more
Before I got my cookstove this year we had a wood burner for our home. Hubby built a building outside that looked like a fancy outhouse and we put the wood burner in there. We then got the insulated pipe and duct it ourselves into the house. Worked great, many evenings we had a window opened cause we was a bit to warm. Now we did have it duct into the furnace which we used the blower to circulate it. So no electric, we had to run a generator.
I agree with everyone else. Wood heat is so comfy.
Can you get a free standing wood stove and duct it yourself out a wall and run a new insulated pipe instead of using the chimney you have? I guess you would have to compare prices, to fix or put up a new one.
I hope some one can help me out. I live in a single wide with electric heat and no place to put a wood stove. Last year we lost power for 5 days. Any more info on back up heating?
Kerosene. Now I'm talking short term ya know.... A cookie sheet on top makes a good griddle area to cook on. :D

But surely you could sacrifice something for a wood stove? Even if I had to get rid of the kitchen table and eat on TV trays, I'd get some wood heat going especially if you have access to wood. :2thumb:
21 - 40 of 53 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top