Comparison questions - Keychain Nuclear Alert

Discussion in 'General Preparedness Discussion' started by NaeKid, Mar 12, 2010.

  1. NaeKid

    NaeKid YourAdministrator, eh?

    8,000
    10
    After reading about a product in Jerry's stories, I decided to do some more research into it. It is the "Keychain Radiation Detector" that everyone seems to have in his stories. I found prices from around $100 to $200 and I was wondering if anyone here has any real-world experience with either of them?

    Now, I am not expecting a nuke to pop this town, but, that doesn't mean that I wouldn't be going through areas where natural radiation occurs (uranium mines, etc).

    The two products that I found are at:

    RADDETECT RADIATION DETECTOR at Survive4Less

    NukAlert™ Radiation Detector, Meter, Monitor and Alarm

    There might be other products out there as well that I haven't found (yet) - so I am open to alternative suggestions. Which would be the "best" for the "best price". I wouldn't wanna spend $200 on a single one if I can get two keychain-units for that same $200 that has the same level of accuracy.

    I hope you understand, money being what it is, I wanna get the best value for the best product, but, I don't mind paying more if it is the better choice.
     
  2. bunkerbob

    bunkerbob Supporting Member

    1,733
    6
    One of our group members here just bought one, he was driving in a parking lot and it went off. He looked around and noticed he was next to a dentist office, xrays from their equipment I guess.
     

  3. ZoomZoom

    ZoomZoom Rookie Prepper

    4,106
    13,758
    The high price of those units made me shy away as I want to have a few detection units.
    I went with the credit card type units for $30 each. Here's what I'm referring to.
    RADTriage Radiation Detector | No batteries | Instant detection
     
  4. HozayBuck

    HozayBuck Well-Known Member

    3,183
    16
    I'd need one that talked to me, having on in my wallet wouldn't help me, I need a beep or chirp or a "HEY STUPID!! RUN !!" sound...
     
  5. dahur

    dahur Well-Known Member

    209
    0
    IMHO, I believe the only thing those cc types are good for is in the event of an nuclear detonation, or catastrophic accident. In other words, you'll probably never have use for it. It only registers very high radiation. I think you can't re-charge them either. Once they show anything, (like possibly a year long accumulation of background), you can't put them back to zero.

    You can get a dosimeter pen and charger on E-Bay for less than that, that registers much lower radiation. And those can be reset.

    As to the key chain ones. The smaller the Geiger tube, the less sensitive it is.
    Less particles of radiation can be "caught". I think they are usually sensitive to 75 mR/h and over as a general rule. Again, okay for high sources, not too good for the more common lower ones.
     
  6. kogneto

    kogneto The Skeptic

    280
    0
    I've seen a lot of stuff online for making your own Leyden Jars and there's always the Kearny Fallout Meter

    cheaper eh:p
     
  7. NaeKid

    NaeKid YourAdministrator, eh?

    8,000
    10
    Would you happen to know which model your group-member purchased? I don't want something too sensitive (set off walking by a person that just finished ingesting radioactive-water for hospital-tests), but, sensitive enough that would tell me that it might not be a good idea to be in the general area. :gaah:
     
  8. bunkerbob

    bunkerbob Supporting Member

    1,733
    6
    It was this one... NukAlert™ Radiation Detector, Meter, Monitor and Alarm
    Did you see the BOV vids I posted, WOW!!!
     
  9. TechAdmin

    TechAdmin Administrator Staff Member

    2,244
    47
    I like it! I think it would be easier to pack than a Geiger.
     
  10. longtime

    longtime Well-Known Member

    155
    0
    I have had one for years. It goes off when the temperature changes(that is normal), It has gone off around Moab, old mines, but never in the dentist office. It sounds a series of peeps to indicate level of radiation. 1 just a little above back ground ( 42 days to get 100 R exp.), 10 run like hell (<2 hours to 100 R. exp.).
     
  11. longtime

    longtime Well-Known Member

    155
    0
    Mine is the Nukalert